Starter 1999 card list and prices
Magic · Magic: The Gathering · released 1999-04-05 · 173 cards
Soldrecent eBay sales (PriceCharting)Marketcurrent TCGplayer listing pricedimmed = sold price unreliable for this printing
Angel of Light
#1 · Uncommon
$4.39$5.20
Angel of Mercy
#2 · Uncommon
$1.60$1.45
Angelic Blessing
#3 · Common
$0.12 (unreliable: multiple products mapped)$0.15
Archangel
#4 · Rare
$0.51$0.57
Ardent Militia
#5 · Uncommon
$0.24$0.23
Armageddon
#6 · Rare
$11.56$16.01
Bargain
#7 · Uncommon
$1.25$1.25
Blinding Light
#8 · Rare
$1.01$0.82
Border Guard
#9 · Common
$0.31$0.14
Breath of Life
#10 · Uncommon
$0.68$0.52
Champion Lancer
#11 · Rare
$3.18$3.65
Charging Paladin
#12 · Uncommon
$0.21$0.19
Devoted Hero
#13 · Common
$0.24$0.20
Devout Monk
#14 · Common
$0.40$0.28
Eager Cadet
#15 · Common
$0.15$0.15
False Peace
#16 · Uncommon
$0.44$0.50
Foot Soldiers
#17 · Common
$0.35$0.16
Gerrard's Wisdom
#18 · Rare
$1.49$0.19
Knight Errant
#19 · Common
$0.38$0.08
Loyal Sentry
#20 · Rare
$1.73$1.38
Path of Peace
#21 · Common
$0.15$0.05
Righteous Charge
#22 · Uncommon
$0.38$0.42
Righteous Fury
#23 · Rare
$11.06$10.73
Royal Falcon
#24 · Common
$0.14$0.09
Royal Trooper
#25 · Uncommon
$0.41$0.32
Sacred Nectar
#26 · Common
$1.19$0.20
Steadfastness
#27 · Common
$0.19$0.19
Venerable Monk
#28 · Common
$0.40$0.23
Vengeance
#29 · Uncommon
—$0.42
Veteran Cavalier
#30 · Uncommon
$0.98$0.61
Wild Griffin
#31 · Common
$0.40$0.29
Air Elemental
#32 · Uncommon
$0.65$0.26
Coral Eel
#33 · Common
$0.17$0.16
Counterspell
#34 · Uncommon
$2.67$2.77
Denizen of the Deep
#35 · Rare
$1.93$0.95
Exhaustion
#36 · Uncommon
$0.35$0.22
Extinguish
#37 · Common
$0.25$0.25
Eye Spy
#38 · Uncommon
$0.27$0.22
Giant Octopus
#39 · Common
$0.13$0.22
Ingenious Thief
#40 · Common
$0.12$0.26
Man-o'-War
#41 · Uncommon
$2.00$2.04
Merfolk of the Pearl Trident
#42 · Common
$0.08$0.06
Owl Familiar
#43 · Uncommon
$0.94$1.07
Phantom Warrior
#44 · Rare
$1.30$1.30
Piracy
#45 · Rare
$56.98$56.98
Psychic Transfer
#46 · Rare
$0.35$0.32
Ransack
#47 · Rare
$0.32$0.31
Relearn
#48 · Uncommon
$0.99$0.75
Remove Soul
#49 · Common
$0.26$0.27
Sea Eagle
#50 · Common
$0.36$0.10
Sleight of Hand
#51 · Common
$1.38$1.46
Snapping Drake
#52 · Common
$0.50$0.25
Storm Crow
#53 · Common
$0.40$0.41
Tidings
#54 · Uncommon
$1.13$1.13
Time Ebb
#55 · Common
$0.15$0.08
Time Warp
#56 · Rare
$16.50$27.84
Touch of Brilliance
#57 · Common
$0.16$0.19
Undo
#58 · Uncommon
$0.32$0.30
Vizzerdrix
#59 · Rare
$0.45$0.43
Water Elemental
#60 · Uncommon
$0.48$0.44
Wind Drake
#61 · Common
$0.13$0.18
Wind Sail
#62 · Uncommon
$0.63$0.31
Abyssal Horror
#63 · Rare
$1.39$0.75
Ancient Craving
#64 · Rare
$2.02$2.09
Bog Imp
#65 · Common
$0.40$0.17
Bog Raiders
#66 · Common
$0.40$0.20
Bog Wraith
#67 · Uncommon
$0.59$0.23
Chorus of Woe
#68 · Common
$0.26$0.22
Coercion
#69 · Uncommon
$0.67$0.17
Dakmor Ghoul
#70 · Uncommon
$2.25$2.12
Dakmor Lancer
#71 · Rare
$0.69$0.44
Dakmor Plague
#72 · Uncommon
$0.41$0.31
Dakmor Scorpion
#73 · Common
$0.52$0.24
Dakmor Sorceress
#74 · Rare
$7.01$6.89
Dark Offering
#75 · Uncommon
$0.40$0.30
Dread Reaper
#76 · Rare
$1.00$1.06
Feral Shadow
#77 · Common
$0.34$0.07
Gravedigger
#78 · Uncommon
$0.24$0.24
Grim Tutor
#79 · Rare
$63.00$104.08
Hand of Death
#80 · Common
$0.10$0.17
Hollow Dogs
#81 · Common
$0.47$0.16
Muck Rats
#81 · Common
$0.75$0.41
Howling Fury
#82 · Uncommon
$0.45$0.40
Mind Rot
#83 · Common
$0.31$0.11
Raise Dead
#85 · Common
$0.12$0.13
Ravenous Rats
#86 · Uncommon
$0.55$0.55
Scathe Zombies
#87 · Common
$0.20$0.24
Serpent Warrior
#88 · Common
$0.68$0.08
Shrieking Specter
#89 · Uncommon
$1.00$1.01
Soul Feast
#90 · Uncommon
$0.22$0.21
Stream of Acid
#91 · Uncommon
$1.51$1.58
Wicked Pact
#92 · Rare
$2.12$2.06
Cinder Storm
#93 · Uncommon
$0.70$0.64
Devastation
#94 · Rare
$14.73$17.57
Earth Elemental
#95 · Uncommon
$0.24$0.22
Fire Elemental
#96 · Uncommon
$0.96$0.90
Fire Tempest
#97 · Rare
$1.93$1.13
Goblin Cavaliers
#98 · Common
$1.15$0.20
Goblin Chariot
#99 · Common
$0.50$0.14
Goblin Commando
#100 · Uncommon
$1.01$0.66
Goblin General
#101 · Uncommon
$6.50$6.77
Goblin Glider
#102 · Uncommon
$0.25$0.24
Goblin Hero
#103 · Common
$0.18$0.22
Goblin Lore
#104 · Uncommon
$5.04$5.54
Goblin Mountaineer
#105 · Common
$0.50$0.29
Goblin Settler
#106 · Uncommon
$7.37$7.49
Hulking Goblin
#107 · Common
$0.14$0.11
Hulking Ogre
#108 · Uncommon
$0.35$0.20
Jagged Lightning
#109 · Uncommon
$0.40$0.26
Last Chance
#110 · Rare
$5.75$5.49
Lava Axe
#111 · Common
$0.15$0.12
Mons's Goblin Raiders
#112 · Common
$0.71$0.12
Ogre Warrior
#113 · Common
$0.10$0.10
Raging Goblin
#114 · Common
$0.20$0.23
Relentless Assault
#115 · Rare
$5.48$5.52
Scorching Spear
#116 · Common
$0.99$0.08
Spitting Earth
#117 · Uncommon
$0.22$0.22
Stone Rain
#118 · Common
$0.56$0.56
Thunder Dragon
#119 · Rare
$12.25$13.43
Trained Orgg
#120 · Rare
$0.32$0.25
Tremor
#121 · Common
$0.25$0.24
Volcanic Dragon
#122 · Rare
$0.58$0.58
Volcanic Hammer
#123 · Common
$0.31$0.27
Alluring Scent
#124 · Rare
$3.93$3.84
Barbtooth Wurm
#125 · Common
$0.71$0.67
Bull Hippo
#126 · Uncommon
$0.19$0.19
Durkwood Boars
#127 · Common
$0.32$0.10
Gorilla Warrior
#128 · Common
$0.15$0.14
Grizzly Bears
#129 · Common
$0.18$0.17
Lone Wolf
#130 · Common
$0.37$0.33
Lynx
#131 · Uncommon
$1.15$1.28
Monstrous Growth
#132 · Common
$0.10$0.10
Moon Sprite
#133 · Uncommon
$0.21$0.19
Natural Spring
#134 · Uncommon
$0.40$0.38
Nature's Cloak
#135 · Rare
$6.74$7.21
Nature's Lore
#136 · Common
$3.12$3.21
Norwood Archers
#137 · Common
$0.40$0.35
Norwood Ranger
#138 · Common
$0.35$0.16
Pride of Lions
#139 · Uncommon
$0.84$0.73
Renewing Touch
#140 · Uncommon
$1.09$1.02
Silverback Ape
#141 · Uncommon
$3.75$3.75
Southern Elephant
#142 · Common
$0.40$0.39
Squall
#143 · Common
$0.32$0.33
Summer Bloom
#144 · Rare
$5.17$5.88
Sylvan Basilisk
#145 · Rare
$1.40$1.07
Sylvan Yeti
#146 · Rare
$6.88$1.47
Thorn Elemental
#147 · Rare
$0.98$0.64
Untamed Wilds
#148 · Uncommon
$0.76$0.48
Whiptail Wurm
#149 · Uncommon
$0.49$0.48
Whirlwind
#150 · Rare
$1.14$0.99
Wild Ox
#151 · Uncommon
$0.30$0.22
Willow Elf
#152 · Common
$0.31$0.31
Wood Elves
#153 · Uncommon
$3.44$4.04
Plains (154)
#154 · Common
—$0.82
Plains (155)
#155 · Common
—$0.41
Plains (156)
#156 · Common
—$0.56
Plains (157)
#157 · Common
—$0.54
Island (158)
#158 · Common
—$0.54
Island (159)
#159 · Common
—$0.62
Island (160)
#160 · Common
—$0.59
Island (161)
#161 · Common
—$0.47
Swamp (162)
#162 · Common
—$0.76
Swamp (163)
#163 · Common
—$1.20
Swamp (164)
#164 · Common
—$0.41
Swamp (165)
#165 · Common
—$0.77
Mountain (166)
#166 · Common
—$0.58
Mountain (167)
#167 · Common
—$0.61
Mountain (168)
#168 · Common
—$0.56
Mountain (169)
#169 · Common
—$0.73
Forest (170)
#170 · Common
—$0.51
Forest (171)
#171 · Common
—$0.53
Forest (172)
#172 · Common
—$0.37
Forest (173)
#173 · Common
—$0.70
Working through Starter 1999?
Scan the set into a collection that tracks its own value, and see at a glance which cards you still need.